Drawing
a stark comparison between incomes and expenditure of Indian citizens,
finance minister Arun Jaitley in the Union budget speech implied that
tax evasion is a serious problem in the county. He said, "The number of
people showing income more than Rs50 lakh in the entire country is only
1.72 lakh. We can contrast this with the fact that in the last five
years, more than 1.25 crore cars have been sold, and number of Indian
citizens who flew abroad, either for business or tourism, is 2 crore in
the year 2015. From all these figures we can conclude that we are
largely a tax non-compliant society."
And the government intends to tackle this by the implementation of
the goods and services tax (GST). While draft GST rules on various
aspects aim to bring in more transparency; maintaining records of
different entities involved in every transaction appears quite tedious.
It also means higher cost of compliance.
Apart
from that, working capital requirements for manufactures would soar too
because both companies and distributors will have to pay GST at the
time of dispatch of stock even if supplied to own warehouses, and
subsequently claim credit on the input tax so paid. The input tax credit
mechanism will entirely be online and real time. Therefore, it would
pinch small and medium enterprises (SMEs) the most.
"The way the
law is stated today, cost of compliance is not just going to go high;
small and medium businesses are going to be in deep trouble. Linkage of
input tax credit to payment of supplier tax is very dangerous for the
small business community and therefore for a very large part of the
economy," said Tejas Goenka, executive director at Tally Solutions.
Also,
since uploading of each invoice has to be done on a regular basis, an
accountant may have to be designated for this purpose, which small
businesses may not be able to afford, added some tax experts.
For
smooth transition, a slew of accounting and tax firms have been
operating as licensed GST Suvidha Providers. They will help businesses
to comply better with GST processes and depending on the kind of product
or service for which assistance is required, charges will be levied.
"The charges range from Rs500-5,000 depending on the kind of service and
for small companies incurring such expenditure may hurt their margins.
As far as service providers are concerned, decentralized registration
will be an additional cost burden for them," said S.S. Gupta, editor at
Taxmann.
According to a recent channel check by Edelweiss
Securities Ltd, while large consumer goods companies are GST-ready with
IT systems in place, the scenario with other stakeholders, i.e.
distributors and wholesalers, is completely different. Many wholesalers
are currently outside the tax bracket and a few are improving their
margins solely by way of tax evasion, so some pushback is anticipated
from their end, said the brokerage house.
But since wholesale
constitutes 35-45% of overall trade in India, Edelweiss expects large
consumer goods firms to encourage wholesalers to come into the organized
sector. "This could push up overall distribution costs of companies,
which in our view should not be more than 50-60 basis point and will be a
one-time exercise as the same can be easily passed on to consumers,"
added the Edelweiss report.
While it remains to be seen to what extent tax evasion reduces in the GST era, compliance cost is sure to rise.