Later this week, the goods and services tax (GST) Council made up of
finance ministers of states and Union territories and headed by finance
minister Arun Jaitley will convene in Srinagar. The 14th meeting of the
GST Council is important in ways that go beyond the listed agenda: the
complex task of fitting various goods and services into four tax slabs.
It will, at least on the 18-19 May, provide an opportunity to
feature Srinagar and of course the state of Kashmir in a refreshingly
new light in the national media. Instead of the daily news reports on
terrorist encounters/killings/assaults sponsored from across the border,
Srinagar will serve as ground zero for crucial deliberations on GST,
the most singular piece of indirect tax reform attempted in modern
India—and that too in its last mile.
Indeed, it is a very
opportune moment to begin rewriting the narrative on Kashmir and the
emerging compact of federalism, where the Union government is just the
first among equals. The import of this moment cannot be ignored.
For
the first time, Kashmir will be integrating into a national policy
dialogue. And in the case of GST, it will, among other things, eliminate
tariff barriers between states, preclude the cascading effects present
in the existing form of indirect taxes and economically unify India—a
very powerful idea in itself: One Nation, Uniform Tax.
Both the
states and Union government have sacrificed their taxation powers and
instead undertaken an incredible pooling of their sovereignty—Kashmir
has volunteered so wholeheartedly to be part of this despite the fact
that given its special status under the Constitution of India it is not
bound to implement the GST.
This is a perfect example of
the emerging new federal compact, where states are now beginning to own
policy decisions instead of treating it like a step child of the Union
government. As a result, unlike in the last 70 years, the states will be
equal stakeholders; right now it is restricted to the economy, but can
be extended to other domains too.
The first step in this direction
was provided by the Fourteenth Finance Commission which sharply
increased the share of states in net tax receipts of the Union
government from 32% to 42%; did away with grants, gave greater leeway to
fiscally responsible states to borrow and most importantly allowed
states to define their social development programmes so as to tailor
them to the peculiarities of each state.
Prime Minister Narendra
Modi signalled as much in his letter to the chief ministers immediately
after the Union government accepted the Commission’s proposals when he
said, "This is all towards the fulfilment of my promise of co-operative
federalism. As you have already seen, we have decided to involve states
in discussing and planning national priorities."
This emerging
federal institutional framework has been further reinforced by the
formation of the GST Council. It has been designed in such a way that
the Union government has only one-third say in decisions, while the
states account for the rest. Further, all decisions have to be carried
by a three-fourth majority.
To put it simply, going forward, the
Centre and states are enjoined in a three-legged race—one which they can
win only if they coordinate their actions. And in this, it is extremely
creditable that in 13 deliberations of the Council so far, despite
grave provocations and differences among its members, decisions have
been eventually carried by consensus.
It is in this backdrop that
Srinagar will play host to the finance ministers of 32 states and Union
territories. Yes, the final outcome of this key crucial GST Council is
very important as the scheduled roll-out of the GST depends on it. But
equally so is the opportunity it provides to chart a new narrative on
the participation of India’s northern-most state, going through one its
most troubled moments, in a new national dialogue—a Srinagar declaration
as it were.
Undoubtedly, a moment to seize.
Anil Padmanabhan is executive editor of Mint and writes every week on the intersection of politics and economics.
15 May 2017, 01:47 PM